The CSG Actuarial Premium Rate Scorecard™ provides an overall premium rate competitiveness ranking by company across all states, plans, ages, genders, households, and zip codes, based on actual Medicare Supplement quotes completed on CSG Actuarial’s Market Advisor quoting tools.

Based on the demographics of actual Medicare Supplement quotes completed in May 2021, the 20 most competitive Medicare Supplement companies for all plans combined as of June 1, 2021 according to CSG’s Premium Rate Scorecard™ are:

1United States Fire
2American Financial Security Life Insurance Company
3Manhattan Life Group
4State Mutual
5Liberty Life Group
6Independence American
7Royal Arcanum
8United Insurance Company of America
9 Lumico
10Central States
11Accendo
12Atlantic Coast Life
13Federal Life Insurance Company
14Nassau Life
15Erie Family Life
16Catholic Life
17Southern Guaranty Insurance Company
18Americo
19Union Security Insurance
20Medica

Based on the demographics of actual Medicare Supplement quotes completed in May 2021, the 20 most competitive Medicare Supplement companies for Plan F as of June 1, 2021 according to CSG’s Premium Rate Scorecard™ are:

1American Financial Security Life Insurance Company
2United States Fire
3Central States
4Royal Arcanum
5Manhattan Life Group
6Accendo
7Independence American
8Liberty Life Group
9State Mutual
10Federal Life Insurance Company
11United States Fire
12Medica
13Physicians Life
14United Insurance Company of America
15Atlantic Coast Life
16WMI Mutual Insurance Company
17Lumico
18Humana
19Americo
20Prosperity Life

Based on the demographics of actual Medicare Supplement quotes completed in May 2021, the 20 most competitive Medicare Supplement companies for Plan G as of June 1, 2021 according to CSG’s Premium Rate Scorecard™ are:

1United States Fire
2State Mutual
3Manhattan Life Group
4United Insurance Company of America
5Liberty Life Group
6Independence American
7American Financial Security Life Insurance Company
8Old Surety
9Erie Family Life
10Royal Arcanum
11Lumico
12Atlantic Coast Life
13Federal Life Insurance Company
14United Healthcare
15Accendo
16Catholic Life
17Central States
18Union Security Insurance
19Southern Guaranty Insurance Company
20Medica

Based on the demographics of actual Medicare Supplement quotes completed in May 2021, the 20 most competitive Medicare Supplement companies for Plan N as of June 1, 2021 according to CSG’s Premium Rate Scorecard™ are:

1American Financial Security Life Insurance Company
2Manhattan Life Group
3United States Fire
4Liberty Life Group
5Federal Life Insurance
6State Mutual
7Medica
8Royal Arcanum
9Nassau Life
10Lumico
11Independence American
12Catholic Life
13Accendo
14Central States
15Southern Guaranty
16Union Security Insurance
17WMI Mutual Insurance Company
18Atlantic Coast Life
19Aetna
20Prosperity Life