The CSG Actuarial Premium Rate Scorecard™ provides an overall premium rate competitiveness ranking by company across all states, plans, ages, genders, households, and zip codes, based on actual Medicare Supplement quotes completed on CSG Actuarial’s Market Advisor quoting tools.

Based on the demographics of actual Medicare Supplement quotes completed in November 2019, the 15 most competitive Medicare Supplement companies as of December 1, 2019 according to CSG’s Premium Rate Scorecard™ are


RankAll PlansPlan FPlan GPlan N
1Southern GuarantySouthern GuarantySouthern GuarantyCatholic Life
2Atlantic Coast LifeCatholic LifeState MutualCentral States
3Catholic LifeState MutualCatholic LifeSouthern Guaranty
4State MutualLumicoLumicoAtlantic Coast Life
5Central StatesProsperity LifeAtlantic Coast LifeProsperity Life
6LumicoAmericoCentral StatesEquitable Group
7Prosperity LifeGuarantee TrustProsperity LifePuritan Life
8AssurantHumanaEquitable GroupAetna
9Equitable GroupAssurantAssurantLumico
10Guarantee TrustAetnaOld SuretyAssurant
11AetnaPan AmericanHumanaState Mutual
12AmericoEquitable GroupManhattan GroupPan American
13Pan AmericanPuritan LifeGuarantee TrustGuarantee Trust
14HumanaErie LifePan AmericanHumana
15Puritan LifeNational GuardianAetnaManhattan Group