The CSG Actuarial Premium Rate Scorecard™ provides an overall premium rate competitiveness ranking by company across all states, plans, ages, genders, and ZIP Codes.

According to CSG’s Premium Rate Scorecard™, the top 10 Medicare Supplement companies as of April 1, 2014 are:

RankCompany
1Wellpoint
2HCSC
3BCBS of MA
4Wellmark
5BCBS of FL
6Highmark
7BCBS of MI
8BCBS of NC
9BS of CA
10BCBS of MN

The top 10 Medicare Supplement companies as of April 1, 2014 for Plan N only are:

CompanyEffective DateAverage IncreaseComments
American Continental Insurance Company5/1 - 6/1/20142.5%0% - 5%; Varies by state
American Retirement Life Insurance Company5/1 - 5/21/20147.5%0% - 8%; Varies by state
Assured Life Association5/1/147.6%0% - 9%; Varies by state
Bankers Fidelity Life Insurance Company5/1 - 6/1/20144.2%0% - 20%; Varies by state
Central States Indemnity Company of Omaha6/1 - 7/1/20144.2%0% - 20%; Varies by state
Combined Insurance Company of America4/1 - 7/1/20145.2%0% - 12.25%; Varies by state
Continental Life Insurance Company of Brentwood, Tennessee6/1/144.3%Maryland
Equitable Life & Casualty Insurance Company4/1/144.0%North Dakota
Everence Association Inc.4/1/144.2%Ohio
Globe Life and Accident Insurance Company (Direct to Consumer)3/1 - 6/15/20143.1%0% - 9.5%; Varies by state
Heartland National Life Insurance Company5/5/1412.0%Mississippi
Humana Insurance Company6/1 - 7/1/20146.4%0% - 10.1%; Varies by state
Medico Insurance Company5/1/1415.0%Oregon
Omaha Insurance Company4/16/14-5.0%Mississippi
Pekin Life Insurance Company5/1/147.7%4.5% - 9.8%; Varies by state
Physicians Mutual Insurance Company3/1/143.1%(13.6%) - 15%; Varies by state
Standard Life and Accident Insurance Company5/1/146.1%0% - 7%; Varies by state
State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company4/1/14-0.3%(4.4%) - 4.7%; Varies by state
State Mutual Insurance Company (Direct to Consumer)3/1/1414.0%Oregon
UnitedHealthcare Insurance Company4/1 - 6/1/20144.9%0% - 10.3%; Varies by state
USAA Life Insurance Company4/1/14-3.3%Ohio
Woodmen of the World5/1/1415.0%Oregon

The top 10 Medicare Supplement companies as of April 1, 2014 for Plan F (High-Deductible) only are:

CompanyMonthly Rate*
Equitable Life & Casualty Insurance Company$101.25
Old Surety Life Insurance Company $101.47
Oxford Life Insurance Company $102.18
American Retirement Life Insurance Company $105.76
Omaha Insurance Company $108.75
Central States Indemnity of Omaha $112.33
Heartland National Life Insurance Company $112.56
Combined Insurance Company $112.75
Philadelphia American Life Insurance Company $113.74
Manhattan Life Insurance Company $114.75
*Rates are for Plan F, lowest non-smoking female, age 65 in the state of Oklahoma

About CSG Actuarial
CSG monitors senior markets to provide the most up-to-date competitive intelligence in the industry. CSG DataMart™ includes premium rate and underwriting information for more than 200 companies. Call 855-861-8776 or email info@csgactuarial.com to learn more.