The CSG Actuarial Premium Rate Scorecard™ provides an overall premium rate competitiveness ranking by company across all states, plans, ages, genders, and ZIP Codes.

According to CSG’s Premium Rate Scorecard™, the top 10 Medicare Supplement companies as of April 1, 2014 are:

9BS of CA
10BCBS of MN

The top 10 Medicare Supplement companies as of April 1, 2014 for Plan N only are:

CompanyEffective DateAverage IncreaseComments
American Continental Insurance Company5/1 - 6/1/20142.5%0% - 5%; Varies by state
American Retirement Life Insurance Company5/1 - 5/21/20147.5%0% - 8%; Varies by state
Assured Life Association5/1/147.6%0% - 9%; Varies by state
Bankers Fidelity Life Insurance Company5/1 - 6/1/20144.2%0% - 20%; Varies by state
Central States Indemnity Company of Omaha6/1 - 7/1/20144.2%0% - 20%; Varies by state
Combined Insurance Company of America4/1 - 7/1/20145.2%0% - 12.25%; Varies by state
Continental Life Insurance Company of Brentwood, Tennessee6/1/144.3%Maryland
Equitable Life & Casualty Insurance Company4/1/144.0%North Dakota
Everence Association Inc.4/1/144.2%Ohio
Globe Life and Accident Insurance Company (Direct to Consumer)3/1 - 6/15/20143.1%0% - 9.5%; Varies by state
Heartland National Life Insurance Company5/5/1412.0%Mississippi
Humana Insurance Company6/1 - 7/1/20146.4%0% - 10.1%; Varies by state
Medico Insurance Company5/1/1415.0%Oregon
Omaha Insurance Company4/16/14-5.0%Mississippi
Pekin Life Insurance Company5/1/147.7%4.5% - 9.8%; Varies by state
Physicians Mutual Insurance Company3/1/143.1%(13.6%) - 15%; Varies by state
Standard Life and Accident Insurance Company5/1/146.1%0% - 7%; Varies by state
State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company4/1/14-0.3%(4.4%) - 4.7%; Varies by state
State Mutual Insurance Company (Direct to Consumer)3/1/1414.0%Oregon
UnitedHealthcare Insurance Company4/1 - 6/1/20144.9%0% - 10.3%; Varies by state
USAA Life Insurance Company4/1/14-3.3%Ohio
Woodmen of the World5/1/1415.0%Oregon

The top 10 Medicare Supplement companies as of April 1, 2014 for Plan F (High-Deductible) only are:

CompanyMonthly Rate*
Equitable Life & Casualty Insurance Company$101.25
Old Surety Life Insurance Company $101.47
Oxford Life Insurance Company $102.18
American Retirement Life Insurance Company $105.76
Omaha Insurance Company $108.75
Central States Indemnity of Omaha $112.33
Heartland National Life Insurance Company $112.56
Combined Insurance Company $112.75
Philadelphia American Life Insurance Company $113.74
Manhattan Life Insurance Company $114.75
*Rates are for Plan F, lowest non-smoking female, age 65 in the state of Oklahoma

About CSG Actuarial
CSG monitors senior markets to provide the most up-to-date competitive intelligence in the industry. CSG DataMart™ includes premium rate and underwriting information for more than 200 companies. Call 855-861-8776 or email to learn more.